DMCA Takedown Database Takes Itself Out Of Search Results

By Greg Sterling


The irony here is almost too obvious to mention: an entity dedicated to monitoring the potential “chilling effects” of DMCA takedown notices is censoring itself. has now removed itself from search results, making those notices harder to find. was created in roughly 2001 as an academic and public resource to monitor and record potentially improper DMCA requests. Google since roughly 2002 has been sending takedown notices to Chilling Effects to be archived and recorded. The site is still available and online but now more difficult to find for those who don’t already know about it.

Many copyright owners and the Copyright Alliance had complained that Chilling Effects defeated the purpose of takedown notices and had effectively become a search engine for pirated content. Just as Google would remove the disputed links, Chilling Effects republished them in a searchable database. That use case was disputed by Chilling Effects’ defenders.

In particular the Copyright Alliance didn’t like the verbatim publishing of takedown notices that included “personal contact information.” It also didn’t like the implication that those using the DMCA were “proponents of censorship.”

Below is a statement (via TechDirt) from Sandra Aistars of the Copyright Alliance provided to coincide with an early 2014 hearing before the House Judiciary Committee. It explains the group’s objection to Chilling Effects:

The activities of are repugnant to the purposes of Section 512. Data collected by high-volume recipients of DMCA notices such as Google, and senders of DMCA notices such as trade associations representing the film and music industries demonstrate that the overwhelming majority of DMCA notices sent are legitimate, yet the site unfairly maligns artists and creators using the legal process created by Section 512 as proponents of censorship. Moreover, by publishing the personal contact information of the creators sending notices (a practice …read more

Source:: SearchEngineLand


Better Results Start Here Call Now 231-680-0624
 Organic SEO
Rated 4.8/5 based on 38 reviews
Web Design Traverse City
Rated 4.8/5 based on 19 reviews
Rated 4.7/5 based on 36 reviews
SEO Companies
Rated 4.8/5 based on 29 reviews
Social Media
Rated 5.0/5 based on 12 reviews
Reputation Management
Rated 5.0/5 based on 16 reviews
Google Penalty Recovery
Rated 5.0/5 based on 9 reviews
Web Design
Rated 4.7/5 based on 47 reviews